by Rob Harding

Overpopulation: Toying With Extinction
“Overpopulation: Toying With Extinction” by Taro Istok is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

Recently, Margaret Pyke Trust’s Chief Executive David Johnson boldly asserted “The elephant left the room quite some time ago; let’s follow.” Of course, the elephant he was referring to is population — a primary driver of environmental degradation and a key conservation issue. Separately, eminent biologist E.O. Wilson described population’s fundamental importance for ecological sustainability as follows: “The raging monster upon the land is population growth. In its presence, sustainability is but a fragile theoretical construct. To say, as many do, that the difficulties of nations are not due to people, but to poor ideology or land-use management, is sophistic.”

Inspired by theWorld Scientists’ 2nd Notice Warning to Humanity, an international campaign seeking a new United Nations treaty on population is now underway as outlined in this article published by The Rewilding Institute earlier this year. About 50 organizations and several thousand individuals have expressed their support for this initiative so far, representing at least 18 countries across 6 continents. The initiative has been nominated for a United Nations SDG Action Award, an ICFP 2018 EXCELL Award, and a Leaders in Energy Four Generations Award. It also helped earn the proposal’s author, Outreach Director Rob Harding, a fourth nomination for Australian philanthropist Dick Smith’s $1 Million Wilberforce Award.

While a new Framework Convention for this purpose might not be appropriate, a new treaty similar to the Paris Agreement, but focused on human population-related issues instead of climate change, could rightly be recommended under the existing UN Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). As things stand now we cannot meet the worthy CBD targets or seriously pursue the moonshot goal of protecting half the planet from human exploitation due to our single species’ global ecological dominance. Advisory Board Member Bill Rees recently described this well. Moreover, the leadership role of indigenous people and communities in defending Earth’s biodiversity should be widely acknowledged and emphasized.

Let’s be frank: This is no time for historical timidity with respect to forthrightly confronting the issues of human overpopulation and continued population growth to prevent or delay progress on this urgent initiative. For that matter, we cannot rely on our current economic system — neoclassical economics — as a solution to our worsening overshoot predicament. We are facing various ecological and human crises now, and those of us advancing this initiative would like to see us, as a global community, act like it.

It’s high time to prioritize family planning as an integral part of conservation policy, including climate policy, in pursuit of resilient, life-affirming communities that operate within planetary boundaries. As resilience strategist Johan Rockström recently shared, we should embrace a transformative, disruptive future where we start thinking and acting outside the box — this includes unprecedented investments in education for all, general equality, health, and family planning. Project Drawdown’s solutions 6 and 7 (educating girls and family planning, respectively) substantiate Rockström’s urgent call to action.

Please consider joining the Facing Future Initiative and encourage others to join, too. We’re in this together so let’s work together.

[Feature Image/Banner – “Water Drop Experiment #8 by Nikhil Verma is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0  ]

14 Replies to “Population: The Elephant Has Left The Room”

  1. I have met Rob Harding. He is indeed a visionary. Family planning is science’s gift to the world. To not have it universally available. is, in the 21st century, a crime against humanity and the planet. Safe legal abortion is also a MUST . The United Nations Population Fund is the world’s most important supplier of FP (not abortion). I am co-founder of 34 Million Friends of UNFPA. Please look it up. Because Republican administrations have defunded UNFPA since Ronald Reagan, we citizens of the USA can take a stand at . But back to Rob. He is a visionary, he is mission oriented, his dedication is something to behold. He is selfless. Come on people, for you, your offspring, for all people and our Planet Earth, do whatever you can to back his proposal and join the Scientists’ Warning Initiative. .

  2. In 1970 Paul Ehrlich and John Holdren developed the following formula to explain the basic causes of environmental degradation: I = P x A x T where I is impact on the environment, P is population, A is affluence, and T is technology. Clearly the main “I” today is climate change. The concern and talk is all about technology as the cause and solution to climate change, while population and affluence are taboos to be avoided. Fixing only one cause out of three is unlikely to be enough to prevent a catastrophe due to climate change. The UN says that the world’s population is likely to increase another 50% before it peaks even though the growth rate continues to drop. Furthermore, the billions of people who are poor do not want to remain poor but consume like us Americans. If the expected 11 billion people want to live in affluence like us, there is no technology that can do the job. Thus, we need to act to reduce the peak world population and find a better way to live than through affluence.

  3. Write more please! That’s all I have to say, literally. It seems as though you rely on the video to make your point. You clearly know what you’re talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting videos, when you could be giving us something even more enlightening to read and understand?

  4. I am proud to say that the platform of the Democratic Party of Wisconsin reflects the need for a stable population size. . Here is the wording from the 2018 platform (page 5) that can be found at

    4. Climate change poses an existential threat to life on Earth. We support aggressive action to cut carbon
    5. emissions, enhance carbon sinks, and mitigate effects of climate change. Protecting ecological systems
    6. is essential to the economic and social welfare of our state, nation, and the future of humanity. Our
    7. legislators and leaders must pay heed to soil, water, and atmospheric pollution; scientific evidence of
    8. climate change; all invasive species; and decreasing biodiversity. Ecological sustainability requires a
    9. stable population and responsible consumption.
    11. We must maintain the integrity of our vast surface and subsurface fresh water supply, especially the
    12. Great Lakes. We support retaining and expanding publicly owned recreational and wildlands.

  5. Overpopulation is a fascist term – if you want to stop it, start with yourself. It is extremely cynical when rich country population with giant climate footprint talk to poor country population with minimal climate footprint about regulation of overpopulation. Climate justice is just about this – removing that reality distorting fascist overpopulation perspective from a global climate discussion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.